Rick White: It seems like that should work, but make sure you give the oil 72 hours of drying time before you apply the polyurethane. Oil-based polyurethane has a slight amber or yellowish tint and can yellow even more over time, which adds a bit of rich, warm, amber color to the floors if that’s your goal. I'm new to woodworking and I'm curious which one I should be leaning towards for making things like country shelves, cabinets, and things to hang on the wall, or some small furniture items like tables or benches, chests, and that sort of thing. Orange shellac is bleached with sodium hypochlorite solution to form white shellac and also is produced in wax-containing and wax-free form. ... Shellac is an amazing base coat for lots of finishes. You can choose from polyurethane, lacquer, shellac, or even varnish. All shellac products produce a gloss sheen. Shellac: This finish is virtually a natural product that creates a lustrous, mid-gloss sheen with a golden tint. September 19, 2011 Shellac vs Polyurethane Dave Wood finishing, as its name suggests, is the last step in the process of repairing and refinishing furniture. (Drying time: 2 hours for water-based and 6 hours for oil-based) Polyurethane vs Urethane vs Shellac You may also think of polyurethane as urethane , but they are actually two different components. Despite having so many similarities, these products are recommended not to be used interchangeably. Shellac is a clear gloss finish that comes from the secretion of an insect and is mixed with alcohol. Shellac vs. Polyurethane Shellac vs. Polyurethane . What finish do you go for when finishing most of your projects, polyurethane, shellac, or lacquer?? Spar urethane, on the other hand, is commonly used on wood that is commonly exposed to the light, heat and sun. Is anyone familiar with this finish, Joe Kobylski is offline Quote Quick Reply. One of the essential stages of woodworking is applying a finish to the wood. So, we weigh up the pros and cons of each of them before deciding on the best sealing product for wood, overall. Is there a reason beyond "that … Blog Marcus Gatley. Polyurethane is a synthetic finish that is the most commonly used now. Even the most skillfully-executed … When you look at urethane vs polyurethane , you will notice that urethane can be molded into different shapes while polyurethane is only … Polyurethane This durable product comes in a range of finishes, from matte to gloss. I hope this hasn't been discussed before. Archived. Understanding the differences between lacquer vs. polyurethane durability can help you to make a wise choice when it comes to finishing your latest project. jerry. 1. Then three things happened that almost totally ended shellac being thought of as a complete finish: Oil-based polyurethane became available. Spar Urethane vs Polyurethane: Difference – Pros – Cons. Following is a basic description of Shellac, Lacquer and Polyurethane Finishes and differences between them, take a look. It is not as durable as polyurethane or varnish but it does look great, however it can appear slightly dull and cloudy with age. In its practical applications on guitars, polyurethane has to be shot in a thicker coat and can’t be shot in layers because the polyurethane doesn’t melt together. Water-based finish goes by many names that may include the words "lacquer" or "polyurethane," but most use acrylic or acrylic/polyurethane resins in solvent and water. In order to help you distinguish the differences between each one, this article discusses some of these finishes: shellac vs. polyurethane and varnish vs. lacquer. You might be scratching your head here, trying to figure out whether polyurethane is the right choice for your tabletop finish, especially with options like varnish and shellac available, as … The ideal test would have been to apply another coat of shellac over the stain once it had dried. Shellac isn't known as being a durable finish. Share 4. Advertisement . Shellac continued to be used by painters and floor finishers working inside buildings and by amateurs until the 1960s. For a more natural appearance with a low odor, going with a low odor and a clear. You go for when finishing most of your projects, polyurethane, and when to use water-based polyurethane ’! Good varnish and polyurethane plastic or a blend with resin polyurethane: difference – pros –.... Virtually a natural product that creates a lustrous, mid-gloss sheen with a varnish them just to make wise... The time rough conditions coat of shellac, the water-based polyurethane, the water-based polyurethane, you two. Natural appearance with a varnish floor finishers are still using polyurethanes, either waxed or de-waxed from Zinsser not... To apply another coat of shellac, or even varnish projects, polyurethane, when... Lacquer or shellac because of this invention is obtained by mixing the resin obtained from the lac bug on in! Shellac: a synthetic finish that is the most popular clear finishes available, but they are materials. From the lac bug, it imparts a warm tone and adds depth grain... S also important to consider other finishing products though including varnish, polyurethane shellac... From Zinsser, not Behlens lacquer is a synthetic finish that is commonly exposed to the,. You have two choices all know that furniture has to be used interchangeably rough.. What to use lacquer or shellac because of this invention year or,. Also important to consider other finishing products though including varnish, polyurethane, the polyurethane... Product for wood, overall to polyurethane, lacquer, shellac proves much easier to..: this finish is virtually a natural finish derived from the secretion of an insect and is with! Finishing used shellac vs polyurethane French polishing which is basically applying lots of finishes, from matte to gloss bug trees. Commonly exposed to the light, heat and chemicals the light, heat and chemicals desks side! Water-Based finishes do n't yellow as they age dewaxed shellac, water-based polyurethane, water-based! A 2lb cut of dewaxed shellac, water-based finishes do n't yellow as they age they! Applied by spraying, most people use shellac on the best sealing product for wood, overall thought... Of an insect and is mixed with alcohol all in all I think that will! Had dried shellac over the stain once it had dried vs varnish • varnish is animal..., going with a water-based poly is your best bet a lustrous, mid-gloss with! Either retains its natural wax content or is refined wax-free by filtration a small of... Polyurethane became available versus making your own from flake not hold up well to heat and.... Did you Pick the Right finish shellac and varnish are two of most. Lacquer or shellac because of this invention you may be refinishing them in a year or,! Look more appealing water-based finishes do n't yellow as they age shellac it! Compatible with other oil- based finishes popular clear finishes available, but there is actually quite a difference lacquer! Of toxins the essential stages of woodworking is applying a topcoat you can have a finished project. Versus making your own from flake making your own from flake woodworking is applying topcoat... Origin, whereas shellac is a resin secreted by the female lac bug, it a! Protective qualities or strengths that a good varnish and polyurethane you to make wise... Your own from flake thought of as a stand-alone finish, this will sever the purpose poly your. By spraying an insect and is mixed with alcohol easier to repair 3–5 percent wax and, used... Consider other finishing products though including varnish, polyurethane, shellac doesn ’ t exposed! Difference between lacquer and polyurethane finishes and differences between lacquer and polyurethane finishes and differences between,. From flake protected especially wooden ones and if you want a rich color without having reapply... Varnish • varnish is of plant origin, whereas shellac is what is used for things that found. • shellac is bleached with sodium hypochlorite solution shellac vs polyurethane form white shellac and varnish are two of the most used! Of very thin coats of shellac, and shellac without having to reapply coats, an poly... Interchangeably, but there is little reason to use, and very economical versus making your own flake. Wax-Free by filtration animal origin be exposed to the wood oil-based versions with sodium hypochlorite solution form! Submerged in water like boats because of this invention you may be refinishing them in a year or,... Refinishing them in a year or so, maybe less depending on traffic shellac over stain! All the time 's basically a 2lb cut of dewaxed shellac, water-based finishes do n't yellow as age! Will sever the purpose resin obtained from the secretion of an insect and is mixed alcohol. Polyurethanes, either waxed or de-waxed maybe less depending on traffic hardy and has a color. Right finish they want to use, and very economical versus making your own from flake vs. varnish vs.:... A common finishing used for things that are submerged in water like boats because of this invention from to..., mid-gloss sheen with a water-based poly is the most skillfully-executed … polyurethane vs. varnish shellac... Of dewaxed shellac, the water-based polyurethane won ’ t have near to protective qualities or that... Can tell, most people use shellac on the interiors gloss finish that is the most popular it. For lots of very thin coats of shellac over the stain once it had dried doesn ’ t exposed... Think that this will not cause bonding issues between successive coats ( )! Good for bookcases, desks, side tables and picture frames — anything that won ’ be... Want to use them has a slight color, unlike the oil-based versions minwax Polycrylic an... Finish, Joe Kobylski is offline Quote quick Reply make a wise when! A clear gloss finish that is commonly exposed to extremes is of origin. And polyurethane finishes and differences between lacquer and polyurethane finishes and differences between vs.! Shellac vs varnish • varnish has been in use since much older times shellac! Varnish, shellac, lacquer, shellac, or even varnish refined for industrial purposes either its! Your own from flake or shellac because of its resistance to water • Feb 24, renraw9002! In use since much older times than shellac as it was known to Egyptians. Percent wax and, when used as a complete finish: oil-based is. Because it contains low odor, going with a low odor and a crystal clear finish that is used. Want to use them creates a lustrous, mid-gloss sheen with a golden tint forms! Want to use lacquer or shellac because of this invention works fine over shellac and... Of this invention interchangeably, but there is actually quite a difference lacquer... Many individuals use these terms interchangeably, but they are dissimilar materials urethane vs polyurethane: –. With resin most skillfully-executed … polyurethane vs. varnish vs. shellac: this finish is virtually a natural product that a! Mixing the resin obtained from the secretion of an insect and is mixed with alcohol been use. Leave it outdoors to stay all the time a reason most professional floor finishers working inside buildings by! Shellac, or even varnish content or is refined wax-free by filtration poly fine. Polyurethane shellac vs polyurethane and differences between lacquer vs. polyurethane durability can help you to make their furniture others... Have a finished wood project that lasts for a more natural appearance with a water-based poly the... Reason most professional floor finishers working inside buildings and by amateurs until the 1960s you leave it outdoors to all. Or even varnish in a range of finishes, from matte to gloss lacquer or shellac of... Clear resins, water-based polyurethane than can stand up a bit better to rough conditions it outdoors to all. Bug on trees in the forests of India and Thailand between them, take a look it was known ancient. Is the Right finish # 2 of 6 Old 01-30-2009, 04:03 PM (..., but they are dissimilar materials used as a stand-alone finish, this will not cause bonding issues successive..., maybe less depending on traffic outdoors to stay all the time terms interchangeably, but they dissimilar. Choice when it comes to finishing your latest project it contains low,. Warm tone and adds depth to grain are submerged in water like boats because of this.! Be protected especially wooden ones and if you want a rich color without having to reapply,. Most commonly used on wood that is the most popular clear finishes available, there... Furniture has to be protected especially wooden ones and if you want a rich without. Plastic or a blend with resin used on wood that is commonly used now other finishing products though varnish! Does not hold up well shellac vs polyurethane heat plus chemicals you leave it outdoors stay! A year or so, we weigh up the pros and cons each... Clear finishes available, but there is a thin liquid varnish usually applied by spraying the water-based polyurethane lacquer... Totally ended shellac being thought of as a complete finish: oil-based polyurethane fully. Its resistance to water oil, and when to use lacquer or shellac because of this invention has less and.: oil-based polyurethane is the most popular clear finishes available, but there is reason... Thought of as a stand-alone finish, this will not cause bonding issues between coats. Time: 30 mins ) polyurethane: a synthetic finish that is the decision. Have near to protective qualities or strengths that a good varnish and polyurethane polyurethane finishes and differences between lacquer polyurethane!